Understanding Why International Aid Organizations Need Israeli Permission in Gaza

Currently, Gaza is embroiled in a conflict initiated by Hamas. The consequences of war are dire; innocent lives are lost, and the region faces significant humanitarian challenges. Israel has soldiers stationed in Gaza, providing security within the conflict. This presence raises questions regarding access to humanitarian aid, particularly for organizations like the United Nations (UN) and other non-combatant bodies. These organizations must navigate a complex environment where borders are often blurred between humanitarian and combat operations.

Why Israel Checks Aid Vehicles and Ambulances

The Israeli government checks aid vehicles and ambulances to ensure that they are indeed delivering humanitarian assistance and not facilitating the transport of weapons or other non-humanitarian items. This precaution is due to the ambiguous roles played by some international organizations. For example, there have been instances where aid workers and vehicles have been used to transport armed terrorists, leading to the deaths of border guards.

On the most recent occasion, four border guards died while allowing aid through Gaza. The presence of armed terrorists in aid vehicles and ambulances underscores the need for strict verification processes to maintain the integrity of humanitarian aid efforts.

The UN and Its Lack of Armed Capabilities

The United Nations, as an organization, does not have its own standing army. It relies on member states for support in peacekeeping and humanitarian efforts. Despite the UN's mandate to address global issues, it lacks the military enforcement capability to ensure that its workers and supplies are used solely for humanitarian purposes.

Moreover, the UN acts as a platform for dialogue among the 5 permanent members of the Security Council. This body uses the UN as a facade for global governance and a forum to express opinions, strategies, and policies often aligned with the interests of these powerful nations. The UN is not an independent entity with the ability to impose its will on any given situation.

The Importance of Israeli Consent

Given the current reality in Gaza, where Hamas holds de jure authority and the de facto power is held by the Palestinian factions, international organizations need to obtain permission from Israel. Israel is the occupying force, and it has the right to ensure that humanitarian aid is not being used for nefarious purposes.

Peace and stability in Gaza are dependencies on cooperation and mutual trust. The UN cannot simply walk into Gaza without clearing its intentions with the Israeli authorities. By respecting this necessary protocol, the organization demonstrates its commitment to the principles of humanitarian aid and the well-being of the Gazan population.

Caution in the War Zone

Given the ongoing conflict and potential for crossfire, it is essential for all parties, including aid organizations, to proceed with caution. The risk of unintended consequences, such as being caught in the middle of hostilities or causing harm through poorly executed operations, is very real.

May there be peace in Jerusalem and long may it endure. The situation in Gaza is complex, and while the goal of humanitarian assistance is commendable, adherence to established procedures and protocols is crucial to ensure that aid reaches those in need without causing further harm.